• 0 Posts
  • 43 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle



  • You’re getting downvoted, but you’re right. This knife cuts both ways, and it far predates llms.

    Any non trivial algorithm intended to rank is gameable.

    This is the foundation of SEO. It’s how the Donald invaded reddit. It’s the fucking central pillar of modern propaganda dissemination.

    They’re going to spend a ton of money to lock themselves into an ongoing arms race.

    And if one is morality opposed to this type of pricing practice, I think one becomes morality obligated to do exactly what you described.

    And honestly, I think you don’t even have to come out ahead for it to be worth it. If your LLM assessed price would be 1000, spending a full $200 on compute to game and $800 ticket is a wash. You SHOULD spend $300 to get an $800 ticket if that’s where the floor is. Because fuck em.



  • This is where I’m really fuzzy on the mechanics.

    Any authentication is to establish an identity. At what point does that involve getting a unique id associated with an OS installation instance?

    My original question is how the hardware id and ngrok get associated at all.

    So, after getting frustrated and just going to sign up for an account myself, it looks like ngrok has options to sign is as a Google account, or sign in as a github account.

    I’m guessing they picked github, and that’s why Microsoft had any visibility at all on the fact that they accessed a site that isn’t owned by Microsoft.

    It still doesn’t answer the question of how the browser knows this id which is set at the os level. It still begs the question of what github authentication looks like differently between operating systems. Obviously a osx or Linux machine wouldn’t have that id at all. Is it part of the initial authentication request? Is there some kind of challenge and response?





  • Counterpoint:

    They already are losing money. They themselves do not project that they will be profitable until 2030. The idea that “smart people with spreadsheets won’t let them lose money” is obviously wrong because they have done nothing except lose money, ever.

    They get thier operating capital from funding, not sales.

    Now, I agree that the gambit is wrong. So you’re right. You’re just right for the wrong reason.

    Funding is just the cash value of market optimism for the future of your product. High usage props up optimism. Social media IPOs were valued very much based on active users, the idea being that more users meant more opportunity for profit.

    The more people actively using these tools, even if they’re just maliciously burning tokens, just add to the “active users” metric. Which makes funding easier. And funding is the ACTUAL way these companies “make thier money”.




  • They’re asking us to scale back our usage.

    I give it another year. The markets are souring on it, big time. Unless something big and good happens w/ spaceX (because retail investors are underwater on that) the next set of AI IPOs are going to be a disaster.

    Ask yourself why all these companies are scrambling to IPO now. Thier investors see the writing on the wall: it isn’t going to happen. The breakthrough. The singularity. An army of virtual workers with the ability to actually do the job. The only thing left for investors to do is push the IPOs to get any kind of return.

    They think we’re at a peak of perceived value, and a higher plateau isn’t anywhere in the foreseeable future. Judging by how quickly ALL these private companies are suddenly interested in IPOs, I actually think they think they’ve passed the peak already and are sliding.

    You gotta understand, the C-Suite, even the CTO, need to collectively “paint a picture” for investors. And that is art, and art is subjective. If investors wanna hear “we are prepared to leverage a new technology so that we can remain competitive”, then you gotta paint that picture. The buy in, the double down… take it for what it’s worth.

    Did you think your C-Suite has ever actually been honest with you about plans, priorities, the value proposition of your work… anything really? Don’t ever confuse what they “say” with what the actually think or believe.

    You SHOULD quit, I WISH I was in a position to do so. I’d spin by we could crack a cold one. Hella jealous.

    Just like… for your soul… don’t think this is the new normal. Some neat and good and useful stuff is going to come out of this… but the impact that this tech will have on the workforce is being wildly overestimated.



  • I used to work for a company that did them. Your usual deliverables would be paused, including meetings.

    It wasn’t “more”. They were great. Most of our internal tooling was prototyped that way, and that tooling was super awesome… because it directly solved the real issues we had in our processes.

    My current company is “you can during the designated hackathon events, but you still have to do everything you usually would”. Which is absurd because it means that we don’t always have the option to work late for free.


  • You shouldn’t respect anyone’s opinion: you hear the opinion and judge the contents on it’s own merit. Everyone you respect will have the odd terrible take, and people you loathe will periodically have a banger thought.

    A ton of Dawkins fan boys are huffing copium since the man decided Claude is conscious (and for some incelly reason a woman). A lot of MAGA asshats are trying to torch data centers.

    If you offload your own critical evaluation of ideas merely to an adjudication of the speaker… honestly I hear it no differently than “because chatGPT said”.

    This is just the laziest ad homium. Tell me, what do you think about the content? I am genuinely curious, and that analysis is 1000x more valuable.



  • Or perhaps in some cases, neither, and they’re just developing a narrative that the markets reward.

    My company is laying people off. But also replacing them not with AI, but with contractors. And now, some new designation of “per project contracts” or something.

    Anyhow, net effect? Less work useful work getting done, new cost of AI tools, AI tools not generating any value, and if you count total humans in the mix, it’s at least as many as before.

    Moving our product has never been more expensive and we’ve never done it this poorly before. But the market just sees “layoffs due to AI” and think it’s because we (and others) have cracked the code of how to substitute humans with AI to save labour costs. We haven’t. Not even CLOSE.