• 0 Posts
  • 17 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 5th, 2023

help-circle







  • 10 years is over the horizon of a setting sun.

    The oceans lag 20 years behind the atmosphere and removing the CO2 and methane would take generations with current cutting edge tech.

    There is no viable means to remove methane from the atmosphere at any meaningful scale that does not produce CO2 as a byproduct.

    We are fucked and have known that for over 100 years while we did nothing of value. We jumped off a cliff and expected to find a way to land safely on the way down.


  • Is it nihilistic to accept that you are strapped to a wall while a truck drives towards you at 50mph? There is no technology that can stop or reverse what is happening and what will happen. Optimism in the face of death is ignorance of reality.

    Planting billions of trees can’t remove methane from the atmosphere. Methane is a far more potent greenhouse gas than CO2. The hotter the average temperature, the more the permafrost melts and the more methane is released. Ocean temperatures increasing, currents changing, and the ocean acidifying destabilizes methane hydrates which release even more methane.

    Ocean temperatures rise and acidification increases, corals die. 25% of ocean life depends on corals for part of their lifecycle. We have lost 14% of coral from between 2009 and 2018, 50% since 1950. Since 1970 we have lost 50% of marine life. 3 billion people depend on marine life as their primary protein source.

    Make everybody vegan? You need 1 billion hectares of land, total arable land on Earth is 1.4b hectares. Then take into account that arable land will likely decrease with climate change and crops will be lost every year. Then there are the fresh water needs for the crops. Don’t forget that growing all that food depends on petrochemical fertilizers and diesel farm equipment, not to mention the logistics of moving and processing the crops.

    We can use biodiesel! You need 300 million hectares of land to make enough biodiesel to satisfy global demand at the current needs, which would be dwarfed by the needs of farming 1.3b hectares of land.

    Don’t suggest we go all electric, the energy needs to produce and charge all that are outrageous and infeasible without bottling stars and mining on a scale that would make a Bagger 293 sweat and cry.

    You want me to bring up the 45% loss of insects in 40 years?

    We are fucked.

    Billions of people are going to die, we will watch it happen in our lifetime, and there is nothing that can be done to stop it without a magic wand, a time machine, or a benevolent god’s undeserved mercy.

    You want optimism? I hope the science is wrong.


  • Glacial retreat is part of the natural cycles of glaciation that our planet does. Were we fucked when the cordilleran and laurentide retreated? Absolutely not, it was disastrous for costal inhabitants though because the ocean level went up by 400 feet in the last 15,000 years. If sealevel went up 400 ft again(it won’t, only around 230ft is possible) the Statue of Liberty would be under 100’ of water.

    The methane releasing from the permafrost should be more alarming than glacial retreat. Then there is the oceans decreasing ability to store methane hydrates…

    Atmospheric methane is skyrocketing and there is nothing that could be done about it, save waving a magic wand. Stop all anthropogenic methane and the methane still runs away. Stop all CO2 production and all you do is stop CO2 production.

    You have no idea how fucked we are.