• JollyG@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      11 months ago

      A Tu quoque is when you claim that an argument is wrong because the person making the argument behaves in a way that contradicts the argument’s premises.

      As In:

      1. The CEO of Exon says that industrial emissions of hydrocarbons contribute to climate change.
      2. Exon is one of the single largest hydrocarbon polluters.
      3. Therefore, industrial emissions of hydrocarbons do not contribute to climate change.

      This is a fallacy because someone being a hypocrite does not mean their conclusion is wrong. Pointing out that some response to an argument as a Tu quoque is not the same thing as claiming that you are not allowed to point out hypocrisy, or you are not allowed to assess the credibility or motivations of a speaker. It just means that hypocrisy does not guarantee that someone’s argument is wrong.