https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_flank_effect
The radical flank effect refers to the positive or negative effects that radical activists for a cause have on more moderate activists for the same cause.[1]
According to Riley Dunlap, the idea of a radical flank effect “has a lot of credibility among social-movement scholars”.[2]
Photo: https://wagingnonviolence.org/2022/12/radical-tactics-arent-hurting-climate-movement-research/
Armed radical flanks often protect more moderate nonviolent activists from repression, thereby allowing the nonviolent actions to continue.
Fuck Just Stop Oil.
They’re hurting the environmental movement, I wouldn’t be surprised if they’re paid by oil companies to piss of normal people by pulling stupid stunts
Please explain how they are hurting the environmental movement
They’re environmentalist look like irrational screaming babies.
They’re just pissing people off by throwing paint on famous paintings, by gluing themselves to the road and blocking normal people just wanting to get to work etc. What does this accomplish?
They should go throw paint on yachts and private jets not block people trying to get to work, or glue themselves to F1 tacks stopping people watching the sport they find enjoyment in.
Go protest outside oil company headquarters or outside government buildings, don’t inconvenience every day people.
They are not pissing everyone off. Maybe you are but I’m not. Even though I’m not associated with them in any way
Two things can be true at the same time.
They are definitely pissing people off, like I said, I would not be shocked if they were funded by oil companies to protest in the worst possible ways so people don’t take environmentalists seriously.
It could also be that they piss people off and overall do more good than harm.
How does stunts like vandalising Stonehenge exactly help the cause?
I’m glad to see they’ve disbanded this year.
I’m all for stopping oil, but vandalism of historical monuments and paintings etc. Is not the way to do it
You gotta do what you gotta do. Everyone has lines they won’t cross and lines they will. Either way, as the article demonstrates, it does help the moderate movement perhaps even because because it pisses people off.
What does this accomplish?
What it’s trying to accomplish is forcing you to stop and reassess your priorities. Why are you more upset about blocking a public road or throwing powder on Stonehenge or delaying an F1 race than your ecological future being systematically destroyed? Why do you have such a visceral reaction to these relatively trivial disruptions and not the looming destruction of your entire way of life?
They should go throw paint on yachts and private jets […] Go protest outside oil company headquarters or outside government buildings
They have done these things and it doesn’t do much beyond slightly annoying some rich people. Has any legislation or public effort been advanced from decades of standing outside of government buildings? Has throwing paint on yachts made the rich repent? Has blocking oil pipelines made oil companies dissolve?
Clearly demonstrations against the people who gain the most by this destructive system don’t work, why not bring the message to those who will lose the most?
Do people actually stop and reassess their priorities though? Most just get annoyed at the vandalism and illegal protests.
I stand by their cause, but not how they’re going about it. I’ve heard many others say the same thing.
I still don’t see how vandalising Stonehenge, paintings or disrupting sport accomplished anything.
They should spread their messages, but not through vandalism and disruptions
Idk, worked for me. Different strokes
I get that it would work for some, but it likely alienates others.
It does good but possibly even more harm.
Some people now associate ‘people against oil’ with ‘vandalism & disruption’
Yeah, protest should be quiet, polite, convenient, and preferably invisible. That will no doubt achieve something I guess.
Like with the save the bogs movements, it makes the rest of the environmental movement sound more reasonable mate
umadbro?






